Deep Dive Recap: The Roth Conversion Strategy You Have Likely Never Heard Of

Beyond the Roth Conversion: Exploring PPLI for Legacy Planning

For many affluent families, the challenge is no longer accumulating wealth. It is determining how to preserve and transfer that wealth as efficiently as possible to future generations.

The Joint Committee on Taxation estimates that there are more than 32,000 taxpayers with IRA, Roth, or 401k balances in excess of $10 million. While great tools for accumulating wealth, each has its own significant tax challenges.

In WealthPoint’s recent Deep Dive webinar, Partner Ben Rainey demonstrated how “converting” a traditional IRA or Roth IRA into PPLI dramatically improved wealth transfer outcomes for wealthy families.

Watch the Full Webinar

Who Should Consider this Strategy?

This “PPLI Conversion” strategy could be a fit for the individuals and families who:

  • Have retirement account balances greater than $5 million
  • Do not anticipate needing those assets to support their lifestyle
  • Are focused on maximizing the wealth ultimately transferred to future generations
  • Have a taxable estate

The Growing Challenge of Large Retirement Accounts

Retirement accounts have long been among the most effective wealth accumulation vehicles available. However, when those assets are ultimately intended for children and grandchildren rather than retirement spending, a new set of planning considerations emerge.

Traditional IRAs may be subject to:

  • Income tax
  • Estate tax
  • Income in Respect of a Decedent (IRD) taxation

Inherited retirement accounts are subject to the 10-year distribution rule, potentially accelerating taxation and reducing long-term tax-deferred growth.

While Roth IRAs eliminate future income taxes, they are included in a client’s taxable estate.

As retirement account balances continue to grow, many families are asking whether additional planning opportunities exist.

What’s The IRA Problem?

During the webinar, Ben walked through a case study illustrating how different planning approaches can impact multigenerational wealth transfer outcomes.

Using a hypothetical family with $10 million in retirement assets, the analysis compared the generational wealth transfer of:

  • A Traditional IRA
  • A Roth IRA
  • A “PPLI Conversion”

The case study demonstrated how taxes, distributions, and long-term growth can produce materially different outcomes over multiple generations.

In the example presented, the PPLI strategy created significantly higher projected wealth transfer values than either the Traditional IRA or Roth IRA alternatives. While every client’s circumstances will differ, the analysis highlighted the importance of evaluating all available planning options when legacy objectives are a priority.

Comparing Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, and PPLI Strategies

Ben walked through a case study involving a couple with $10 million in retirement assets. He compared how much could eventually be passed to future generations if they kept the money in a traditional or Roth IRA versus using it to fund PPLI.

The difference was significant.

With a traditional IRA, the case study showed $102 million eventually passing to the third generation. Using the same starting amount to fund PPLI increased this to $545 million when the money was gifted to the trust, or $437 million when a loan was used.

The Roth comparison was striking too. Leaving the money in the Roth resulted in $418 million passing to the third generation, compared with $1.05 billion using the PPLI gifting strategy.

Why such a big difference? In Ben’s modelling, the PPLI structure allowed the money to grow for longer without the same income and estate tax drag, leaving more for future generations.

Questions Advisors Should Be Asking

When reviewing large retirement account balances, consider the following:

  1. Will these assets be exposed to future income taxes?
  2. Will these assets be exposed to future estate taxes?

If the answer to either question is yes, it may be appropriate to explore whether additional planning strategies could improve long-term outcomes for the client and their family.

Would you like to revisit the material covered during the session?

Download the Presentation

Think PPLI Might Be Right For Your Client?

For affluent families with significant retirement assets and a desire to maximize tax-efficient wealth transfer, it may warrant further evaluation.

Talk to us about PPLI

Stay In The Know

Get insights, news, and resources designed to help you grow and steward your wealth.

Keep Learning

Want to expand your expertise? We’ve picked a few insight-rich posts to help you grow your wealth and amplify your impact.

WP90X Recap – Repurposed PPLI Unpacked: Turning Existing Life Insurance Into a Tax-Efficient Asset

Private Placement Life Insurance (PPLI) is not a new concept for most advisory teams. The…

Read More →

Modern PPLI Design and Access to Your Capital

Most advisors underutilize private placement life insurance (PPLI) in an effort to solve a liquidity…

Read More →

Deep Dive Recap: PPLI Liquidity — How Access to Policy Value Works

For many clients and advisors, one of the biggest questions surrounding Private Placement Life Insurance…

Read More →